The famous fish prasadam, believed to cure respiratory disorders, was administered to thousands of people suffering from asthma by the Bathini family here on Monday.
The fish prasadam, earlier known as fish medicine, is given once in a year at the onset of Mrugashira Karti, heralding the southwest monsoon. The prasadam, whose formula is held in secrecy by the Bathini family for decades, is put in the mouth of a murrel fish before it is slipped into the throat of asthma patients.
The Bathini family members, dressed in a traditional attire, started distributing the fish prasadam at 11.00 am. The distribution will continue non-stop will 11.00 am on Tuesday.
The murrel fingerlings were sold for Rs 10 each and were distributed across 32 counters including one for VIPs, physically handicapped, at the sprawling Exhibition Grounds in Nampally here. However, the number of patients this time was comparatively smaller than that of previous years.
However, allopathic doctors, medical researchers and even Ayurveda experts opposed the fish prasadam saying it's unscientific. They said the prasadam is not efficacious and will not cure asthma or any respiratory disease.
Film actor Dr Rajasekhar staged a protest at the venue saying that the fish prasadam has no scientific standing. His actor-wife Jeevita too participated in the protest-cum-awareness campaign. "The way of administering the medicine is harsh and patients are vulnerable to contagious diseases. It has no scientific basis too," said Dr Rajasekhar.
He charged the Bathini family members with neglecting hygiene. People should take precaution while taking the medicine as there's a risk of contacting infectious diseases. The saliva of a patient might stick to the hand of the person administering the fish prasadam and when the person gives prasadam to another patient, it might transmit bacteria, germs or viruses to the latter through the salivary contact", he adds.
Jeevita said she was not in favour of the government supporting distribution of fish prasadam. She alleged that the Bathini family was not ready to prove the medicinal value of the fish prasadam or disclose the ingredients of the medicine. "I doubt there is any scientific basis for this alleged cure and somehow I feel the number of persons coming here is also decreasing because of the unhygienic way of administering the medicine," she adds.
However, patients have a different version to tell. Dr GD Gupta, an ENT specialist from Guwahati who has been suffering from asthma for the last 12 years, said "I have taken this medicine for four years, and I am now completely cured. It is really a miracle medicine for asthma."
"There's nothing wrong in the way of administering the prasad, it is an holy prasad no one can claim it wrong. The Bathini Goud family has been administering the unique treatment free of cost to millions of asthmatics for the last 163 years. Every year lakhs of people come here, not just from different parts of India but even from different countries (Mostly NRIs) which proves that the medicine is curable" claims Mr Bathini Harinath Goud.
For vegetarian people who cannot swallow the live fish, the brothers also offer the Karti medicine, which is in the form of a paste and equally helpful for the disease.Bathini Harinath Goud, along with his brothers B Vishwanath Goud and B Shiv Prakash Goud and family members administered the fish Prasad. The distribution will also later continue at the family residence in Doodhbowli for those who could not take the prasadam.